Messageboard

About Edward from USA:

Re: Songwriters speech (100,482) (100,486) by Edward from USA Sorry, but Mariah isn't an amateur, she's a professional with enough experience under her skirt to know better. All these justifications sound kind of crazy to me. When you've been waiting for the award most important of your career, you plan things up so everything is perfect. You don't show up to your wedding drunk wearing sneakers, you can do that after. She's given great speeches before for less important awards. She could drink herself into next week after her big moment. (Friday 17 June 2022; 20:26)

Re: Songwriters speech (100,478) (100,484) by Edward from USA Exactly my sentiment. She's talked about being a songwriter first and foremost since times immemorial, yet here she is presented with the most important award of her career and what does she do? She gets into her diva outfit and messes it up. But oh well, let me be delusional and say it was just perfect and we must love it because it's Mariah and that's what fans do. I hope people understand why she isn't as respected like the other songwriters and less talented divas, it doesn't have anything to do with her music, it has to do with this unlikable character she thinks people love to watch. And not only that, what kind of outfit is that? Was it a boob and fake ass contest. Lord have mercy. (Friday 17 June 2022; 20:17)

Re: Why I want another #1 (100,368) (100,370) by Edward from USA Rooney: One night, we went to dinner at Sylvia's in Harlem - me, Tommy, and Mariah. On our way back, we were riding in the limo and every club, every car was bumping "Fantasy". Mariah put her sunglasses on, and tears came down her cheeks, because she couldn't believe her record was getting played all through the hood. That was the beginning of her not turning back to pop. She once told me though she was grateful for her success, she would trade in all of her record sales to get the respect that Mary J. Blige got. She said, "Mary doesn't have to sell 28 million records to be respected - people respect Mary, and I just want to be respected like her." You don't write, sing, act or paint for your peers, you do that for the people. Even though your peers respect is always welcomed, the greatest gratification comes from the respect you get from those whom you create your art for, the people. I personally don't have anything against Mariah, she has made her choices and have gained a lot and also suffered the consequences. It's life, we all have gone through that. Let's just not make excuses as to why she's not as respected globally as Celine, Whitney or Barbra. Her choices led to that, she's been in control of her image since Butterfly. (Tuesday 31 May 2022; 18:12)

Re: Why I want another #1 (100,350) (100,363) by Edward from USA That's what you call to pull a Nikki. When you can't pull anything else out of your ass, you can always pull the race card. (Monday 30 May 2022; 21:10)

Re: Why I want another #1 (100,356) (100,362) by Edward from USA "It's silly to claim Mariah Carey isn't respected. But we should probably clarify who we're looking for respect from. 15 year olds?" Exactly, 15 year olds don't know or care about Mariah's music, most people in their their 30's and older are the ones who roll their eyes when her name is mentioned. The peer respect is bullshit, artist want respect from the people, that's the real respect. Back before she could take two steps on her own like the rest of us, while she was still sexy and classy, but before her over the top Diva kicked in, it was cool to say you were her fan, now I keep it to myself. "As for her diva attitude, if using a treadmill in silk negligee and six inch Gucci stilettos while hitting whistles and sipping a glass of crystal pinky out isn't classy, then I don't know what is dahling." Exactly the opposite of classy and sane, dahling. (Monday 30 May 2022; 21:07)

Re: Why I want another #1 (100,330) (100,334) by Edward from USA Celine is a great vocalist, Mariah is a musical genius, but there's a huge difference on how they have portrayed themselves throughout their careers. While Celine has always been classy, Mariah hasn't. Ever since Mariah adopted that diva persona that sometimes comes across as arrogant and petulant, she lost respect and fans jumped ship left and right. She has the instrument, she has the hits, she has the longevity and the status, but she never cultivated an image that would give her that respect. Number and hits don't necessarily give you respect, people do. With all her success, one would think mentioning her name would elicit admiration among friends and people in general, but that's not the case. One also have to consider that her shift in music and decline in the quality of her lyrics/music alienated a huge chunk of her core fanbase. When fans of a certain artist get older, they usually look for more quality unless you're a show-woman like Madonna, whom you can't compare to Mariah in terms of the quality of her music or voice, but someone who offers a show worth every penny you pay for. Different from Celine and Barbra, Mariah is very insecure on stage too, and that usually shows. While she could walk like a regular human being on stage decades ago, she could even run a little, can you image, she could run, but now she's stiff and always in her head. Had she kept being classy as in her Daydream era, she would've been the queen of queens, but it's obvious that's not who she wanted to be. And I'm not talking about her looks necessarily, but her attitude. At some point she believed her own hype and it went to her head. She only has herself to blame. (Friday 27 May 2022; 19:38)

Re: Good afternoon (100,302) (100,304) by Edward from USA Mariah's personal email address is well known. It's Fandelusions@thenerve.com. Make sure you you tell her you're from MCArchives. (Wednesday 18 May 2022; 00:48)

Re: Why Hotlanta (100,269) (100,271) by Edward from USA We need "The Rarities 2" in the meantime. (Thursday 12 May 2022; 16:32)

Masterclass (100,196) by Edward from USA I'm actually speechless after watching the masterclass. Stating you're a songwriter and producer is one thing, but to actually see her working on her songs, it's a breath of fresh air. This is the type of content I thought we would all experience on Mariah's World. I have a new respect for Mariah and her artistry. As much I loved Whitney and like Celine, Mariah is definitely is in a league of her own. The session where she talks about the lyrical contents of "Looking In", "Outside", "The Roof" and "Sunflowers for Alfred Roy" catapulted me back to those days reminding me why I became a fan. As for "The Roof", I can now appreciate it for what it was intended to be, a re-imagened version, not just a ramake. I'm very hopeful for new music. (Sunday 17 April 2022; 15:35)

Brandy (100,182) by Edward from USA Watching Mariah working on "The Roof" with Brandy is actually amazing. They're both sitting on next to each other and Mariah is showing her how the song goes, and then they harmonize each other. So cool. (Saturday 16 April 2022; 00:09)

Re: Mariah Carey Masterclass (100,176) (100,181) by Edward from USA Use a VPN. There are free ones online. (Friday 15 April 2022; 23:13)

Re: The Roof (When I Feel the Need) (100,165) (100,166) by Edward from USA I'm glad you and some others like it. I'll support her with it, but I think Brandy could've be put to better use on it. Maybe what's on YouTube is a rough version, hopefully I change my mind. (Friday 15 April 2022; 02:18)

The Roof (100,164) by Edward from USA That's why I've said that classics should be left alone if they're not going to be improved upon or at least be worked on differently. I love Butterfly the way it is, it's a masterpiece. If this is the way Mariah's going to sound after resting her voice for almost three years, I'm disappointed. What was the use of having Brandy on it, she was basically relegated to background vocals, a waste of talent in my opinion. (Friday 15 April 2022; 01:37)

Conspiracy theory (100,141) by Edward from USA I think some of you should stop with the conspiracy theories. Nobody is blocking Mariah from going to #One if her songs and collabos are filtered by the same rules as everyone else. I would prefer a #One like "Endless Love", "Can't Let Go", "Without You" or "Shake If Off" over a forgettable remix to be honest. I'm not saying I don't like the High Energy Remix, it's just that it's another Fantasy remix to me. (Tuesday 12 April 2022; 22:47)

Re: Where's Bill? (100,064) (100,068) by Edward from USA Easy Mary. Some of us do. (Thursday 31 March 2022; 04:18)

Re: Article: Mariah Carey turns 53 (100,040) (100,046) by Edward from USA At this point in her career having been born in 1969 or a year later doesn't matter, back then it did. I do think she's 53, she should own it. She's had a fascinating career and doesn't look her age at all. (Tuesday 29 March 2022; 16:14)

Re: Any news (99,973) (99,975) by Edward from USA "Sweet Sixteen" would be too girly. "The Woman In Me" would be more appropriate. (Thursday 24 March 2022; 15:58)

Re: Question (99,923) (99,925) by Edward from USA Paula Abdul is just a cold hearted snake. (Thursday 17 March 2022; 18:02)

Re: MC trousers (99,881) (99,887) by Edward from USA Stella once said Mariah had butt implants. I wonder when that happened. Unless Stella was just being bitter and those are push-up panties. (Wednesday 9 March 2022; 19:56)

Re: MC trousers (99,877) (99,878) by Edward from USA What about push-up bras? I think she wore them on her last interview with Oprah. (Tuesday 8 March 2022; 17:33)

Re: Butterfly 25th September 16 (99,865) (99,867) by Edward from USA She re-imagined "One More Try". I hope for some new music. The album Butterfly should be left alone. It is perfect since its conception. (Monday 7 March 2022; 21:09)

Re: Hero (99,850) (99,852) by Edward from USA How dare you having an opinion? I do agree that, lyricwise, "Through the Train" is far superior than "Hero", but I do prefer "Hero". As Terna stated, sometimes less is more, and while "Hero" is kind of generic, its message connected to people and Mariah's delivery was simply flawless. The performance of the song that was used as the video for it, in which Mariah looked like a goddess, represents the Mariah I fell for and the version I also love most. I have to admit though Hero is a song I very rarely listen to, but I do love what it represents in Mariah's career, it definitely was her signature song until AIWFCIY replaced it. (Saturday 5 March 2022; 20:10)

Re: Tommy's Mariah (part 3) breaking down (99,818) (99,821) by Edward from USA Robert-Anthony, we all post here and we know people could comment on those posts, that's a fact. Somebody got their feelings hurt because a fellow board member disagreed with them and they decided to throw a few ridiculous tantrums as if they were 5. Whitney Houston once said: crack is wack, and I agree. (Thursday 3 March 2022; 03:56)

Re: Tommy's Mariah (part 3) breaking down (99,817) (99,820) by Edward from USA Well, given the fact I never addressed you or made any comment on any of your recent posts, and that you've come here attacking me, I have come to the conclusion that you're on crack or something, there's no other explanation. And that wasn't shade, that was a statement. If you don't want people's opinion on your posts, simply don't post. If you're afraid of getting your feelings hurt because someone here disagrees with you, then you shouldn't be posting, you should be in therapy. (Thursday 3 March 2022; 03:48)

Re: Tommy's Mariah (part 3) breaking down (99,803) (99,810) by Edward from USA Come on RibbonC, we all say that, but we read them anyway. We need some drama here, everything is being kind of boring on the board lately. (Wednesday 2 March 2022; 18:02)

MORE MESSAGES