Messageboard

About Bobby A from United States: I have been a Lamb since 1990. I know Mariah. I love her music. I breathe her music.

Eva Langley (114,393) by Bobby A from United States You can blame her popularity on three things. She blew up overnight during March-May. 1. Touring with Morgan Wallen (Mr. Hot 100). 2. Duets with Morgan Wallen (Country radio has worn their duets out like an old pair of Levi jeans). 3. Endorsed as the female George Jones (the Country crooner who was praised for his ability to use his voice to interpret a Country song). (Friday 14 August 2026; 03:31) this is a reply to message 114,390

Eva Langley (114,390) by TJ from Norway I'm not sure if this topic has been up for a discussion earlier, but 17 weeks at number one on the Billboard top 100? I have never heard the name before today. How about you? (Thursday 13 August 2026; 17:25)

A song's quality doesn't come from chart position (114,386) by Bobby A from United States Great post, Randy. I felt MC's labels didn't know how to promote certain singles on Charmbraclet and Caution correctly because the labels wanted that instant Mariah Carey 90s hit. Top 40 radio just doesn't play a new Mariah single like they use to. This top 40 radio exclusion really bothers me because it looks like radio airplay will never go back to Mariah Carey's 90s heyday. I feel the only way this will change is for MC to step out of her box and collaborate on some new non-album singles with pop artists/bands she covered during her career like Steve Perry, Def Leppard, and Foreigner. This approach might help reintroduce MC back on top 40 radio. (Thursday 13 August 2026; 11:00) this is a reply to message 114,384

A song's quality doesn't come from chart position (114,384) by Randy from USA The way you all and MC beat up Through The Rain, Bye Bye, GTFO, IWKWLI is crazy. Those are good songs. There's no magic formula for a #1 or everyone would have one. TTR had a huge marketing campaign. Mariah performed that song on every talk show, award show and mall atrium on Earth. The video was amazing. The vocal is amazing. It's a song that means a lot to me. If the general public didn't care, their loss. I hate hearing her down talk it down now. Why because it peaked at #81? Nothing on Charmbracelet was a great lead single imo. The way she and ya'll beat up Bye Bye irritated me also. She also performed that song at every talk show, late night show and backyard cookout in America. I thought it was a touching song and she killed that climax; it's one of her best. It's also a song many can relate to. Who knows if Migrate would've been a hit. The production quality of Migrate had always sounded muddled to me. Bye Bye peaking at 19 killed the album. And I'm sorry E=MC2 was chock full of singles. It's probably her most commercial album. None of the others did well. So ya'll make out Bye Bye to be Satan's theme. Caution wasn't gonna sell no matter what was released. Mariah is older and nothing on that album is undeniable. A No No is close. Maybe with Cardi on it it woulda done well. IWKWLI was after that type of ballad's popularity but her climax is wonderful. I like the production of the first verse too. My point is MC for the most part puts out quality product. Doesn't matter where it lands chart wise. And is anyone doing the Macarena (#1 for 15 weeks) or singing Old Town Road these days (#1 for 19 weeks)? (Wednesday 12 August 2026; 21:55)

H.A.T.E.U. remix (114,381) by Bobby A from United States I listened to the remix today and it amazed me that the remix probably has MC's best vocals from the Memoirs era. Also, it is probably one of her top 5 remixes built around a popular R&B sample. (Tuesday 11 August 2026; 00:01)

Caution reflections (114,375) by Bobby A from United States I started the Caution topic because MC does not talk much about Caution. I think it is because Epic ruined the album's rollout despite MC delivering her best album since E=MC2. Could a return to Island Def Jam be what MC needs to return to her former glory and label support of the 2000s? (Sunday 9 August 2026; 12:22) this is a reply to message 114,369

Caution reflections (114,369) by Bill from the UK Caution's great but I would have substituted GTFO for either I Don't or Unforgettable. She killed every hope of any radio airplay but releasing that song first. Honestly what the hell was she thinking. (Saturday 8 August 2026; 10:40)

Caution reflections (114,366) by Bobby A from United States Caution was Mariah Carey at her best. Caution was better than MIAM. True or false? Caution should have been just as big as E=MC2. So what went wrong before Caution was released? (Saturday 8 August 2026; 01:29)

Hero (114,365) by Bobby A from United States Le'Andria can sing any song and make it her own. Listen to her songs Better Days and Deliver Me and you will see why she won the singing competition Sunday Best. (Friday 7 August 2026; 00:50) this is a reply to message 114,363

Hero (114,363) by Terna from Nigeria It hits different when you hear it from such a singer. This particular song of Mariah's gets me emotional every single time and reminds me of how far I have come and what I have survived. As the saying goes, "I don't look like what I have been through, neither has my spirit been broken." I am reminded of this every single time I listen to "Hero". Thank you Mariah. (Thursday 6 August 2026; 16:16)

Ariana Grande - Petal (114,346) by Bobby A from United States I am so disappointed in Petal. What is Ari trying to tell us about her future with Republic Records? That might be her Rainbow correlation she was emphasizing. (Saturday 1 August 2026; 01:31) this is a reply to message 114,344

Ariana Grande - Petal (114,344) by nancy from Switzerland I've just listened to Ariana's Petal. It really doesn't sound like MC's Rainbow at all. It sounds more like an 80's popalbum to me. Ariana's voice seems very quite. Without astronomical vocal runs. Mariah's Rainbow is late 90's RnB. The whistle notes in Mariah's [Bliss] are amaaaazzing. Also the runs in [Can't take that away], the Spanish like [After tonight] and those interludes are out of this world. I really don't see any resemblance. But both artists are talented. I'm happy that they respect and admire each other. (Friday 31 July 2026; 14:14)

Can't waut to see who scoffs and mocks this (114,343) by Bobby A from United States Lol. Which two are actually true? MC is the only one who has the answers. (Friday 31 July 2026; 14:00) this is a reply to message 114,341

Can't waut to see who scoffs and mocks this (114,341) by Bill from the UK Ding ding ding. We finally made it to 50. Congratulations to everyone for this collective effort. Be proud. Excuses given for why Mariah can’t move or sing anymore: 1. Ear monitor malfunction 2. No humidifiers 3. Too cold 4. Too hot 5. Stage fright 6. Corset too tight 7. Heels too high 8. Preserving her voice 9. Scared of Michael Jackson's casket 10. Didn't want to upstage the Queen of Soul 11. Wanted to respect her peers 12. Bronchitis 13. Stressful divorce/break up 14. Arm in a sling 15. Pregnant 16. Not pregnant 17. Nodules 18. Too many splashes 19. Medicated 20. Backing singers missed their cue 21. Backing singers singing her part now baby 22. Foiled by Dick Clarke Productions 23. Late for the sound check 24. Not enough sleep 25. Too much sleep 26. Bipolar 27. Food poisoning 28. Mic wasn't turned up 29. Shit happens 30. Avoiding wrinkles 31. Nothing to prove 32. Prioritising her children 33. Too early in the morning 34. Too late at night 35. Broken hip 36. Parkinson’s 37. Alzheimer’s 38. Fibromyalgia 39. Arthritis 40. Dementia 41. Lack of vocal surgery 42. Botched vocal surgery 43. Inadequate breath support 44. Preparing for Christmas shows 45. Rhinoplasty impacting singing ability 46. Breast augmentation impacting singing ability 47. Nerve damage 48. James Packer conspiring to murder her 49. Wants to be left alone 50. Being drugged by an aide in her team (Friday 31 July 2026; 11:43)

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,336) by Bobby A from United States Don't forget their first one together, Can't Take That Away (Mariah's Theme). The song's lack of an independent release was the last straw for MC and her disgust for the label. There are a lot of other things that they did back then like blocking a network Rainbow Tour special on network TV. I am sure Sony Legacy is going to release a barrage of vaulted live performances probably in the next 10 years. (Friday 31 July 2026; 01:21) this is a reply to message 114,333

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,333) by Bill from the UK MC and D-Waz also wrote There For Me as well I believe. (Thursday 30 July 2026; 12:59)

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,329) by Bobby A from United States Sorry, I didn't catch it. I am genuinely concerned about MC. I have been listening to her song Here For It All since I made it to Nashville. It hits differently now that I can really tell MC is at a crossroads with her career because she can't perform like she used to. Here For It All is definitely speaking to everything that I have been through in my life. I know MC wrote it because her life has not been easy since Caution was released. It is a very sad song. (Thursday 30 July 2026; 05:44) this is a reply to message 114,328

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,328) by Lighty from China I know it was all for fun, that's why I used the emoji. (Thursday 30 July 2026; 03:34)

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,322) by Bobby A from United States Edward, I checked with Chap GPT. Of the last 5 movie songs Diane Warren has written, Gonna Be You, The Journey, and Free Woman involved co-writers or featured separate writers. These days her songs for an artist's album are written with the artist. MC has shown in the past that she likes to collaborate with 3-4 songwriters. A Diane Warren collaboration may happen. (Wednesday 29 July 2026; 19:33) this is a reply to message 114,318

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,318) by Edward from USA Diane Warren doesn't like to collaborate and Mariah likes those writing credits, darling. It's not going to happen. (Wednesday 29 July 2026; 13:54)

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,320) by Bobby A from United States It was all for fun according to Diane Warren in this video in 2019. Diane Warren did post on X in 2015 of a "That crazy song." So, there is an unreleased song in MC's vault. (Wednesday 29 July 2026; 17:30) this is a reply to message 114,319

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,319) by Lighty from China Also Mariah picked Diane Warren up and pushed her aside on a red carpet several years ago. She's not gonna want her again. (Wednesday 29 July 2026; 16:30)

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,317) by Bobby A from United States Lol. MC just needs an Areosmith I Don't Want to Miss a Thing moment one last time. Do you remember what that song did for their fading career? By the way, I messaged Diane Warren yesterday to help MC out. (Wednesday 29 July 2026; 12:30) this is a reply to message 114,316

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,316) by Bill from the UK Damn. Our girl’s gonna be in that spotlight for the next 200 years. (Wednesday 29 July 2026; 09:25)

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,315) by Bobby A from United States I believe MC won't leave the spotlight until two or more of the following happens: 1. successful album singles that are radio hits and land in the Hot 100 top 10 2. one more multi-platinum selling album 3. several Grammy wins 4. inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame 5. one more critically acclaim cover similar to Without You 6. one more successful duet collaboration similar to One Sweet Day 7. finally completes her biographical project with Lee Daniels 8. a duet with Kelly Clarkson written with Diane Warren that is long overdue (Wednesday 29 July 2026; 02:09) this is a reply to message 114,313

Leaving the spotlight for a while (114,313) by MusicfanJ from Germany The "team" could find a job by another artist. But I know what you mean. MC should not stay and work for the staff. Just care for herself and children and take some time only for herself. A year is a good thing. Then she could come back with new ideas and energy. She's not twenty anymore, it's okay to "load up the batteries". She has worked enough like for 3-4 lives. She's not 70, but should have some free time and time to relax and live healthier. But she must want it for herself. (Tuesday 28 July 2026; 16:24)

Best ABMB live performance (114,307) by Bobby A from United States I understand better now, but MC has shown us through her songs that she totally gives her all to someone when she truly loves him. Whenever a person falls head over heels with someone, it can be difficult not show some emotional scars after their marriage has ended. MC is a hopeless romantic and it is sometimes difficult for her to let go because she gives her all to someone special. She does not play with someone's heart when she knows that he is the one. MC has become emotional and had to cry and camouflage her tears just to hold on to the memory of their song. I hope she will find love again with someone special. (Tuesday 28 July 2026; 05:06) this is a reply to message 114,305

Best ABMB live performance (114,305) by Edward from USA Putting the burden of your happiness on someone else's shoulders is unfair and unrealistic. Happiness has to come from within. It can't be something another person gives you. I'm not saying things like a breakup, losing someone you love, or other painful experiences can't affect us. They absolutely can. But happiness isn't a permanent state for anyone. People, circumstances, and family can shape us, for better or worse. At the end of the day, though, with or without all the resources and support that some people have and others don't, we're the ones who have to put in the work to heal. I lost my mom when I was 13, and it broke me. It changed me forever because she was my rock and an incredible mother. One day she was there, and the next she was gone, just like that. So I can definitely relate to her grief and pain. I'm really rooting for Mariah to get better, not just for her, but for the twins too. They need their mom. At the end of the day, though, she'll have to get the help she needs because, from what we've been seeing, that's not it. If I were a friend who truly cared about her, I wouldn't be encouraging her to put herself out there like this. Where are the professionals around her? Where are the people looking out for her best interests? I say that because the backlash could end up being even more damaging, especially while she's dealing with so much grief. I think Mariah should step away from the spotlight for a while and focus on herself until she's in a better place. That's just how I see it. Pardon the rant. (Monday 27 July 2026; 13:52)

Best ABMB live performance (114,301) by Bobby A from United States I think we all know who's to blame for MC's sadness - Nick. MC hasn't been the same since 2012. (Monday 27 July 2026; 02:23) this is a reply to message 114,300

Best ABMB live performance (114,300) by Will from England I miss Mariah just smiling naturally during her singing and having fun. Lately she's so wrapped up in not missing her cue or a lyric or not hitting a note, that she's forgotten to have fun whilst performing. This performance is carefree, has improvised moments, interactions, some funny bits, everything that made Mariah's performances so special and personable. Put this performance and then immediately play her piano led moments, and it's two different people. I agree with the other comments, that spark she had for performing has faded, whether it be through medication or otherwise. I had so much trouble connecting with HFIA, because it's overall, it is just a depressing album sonically, vocally and thematically. To me, it speaks of a woman who feels lost, in the depths of depression - a theme continued on from Portrait. It puts me into a depressive mood whenever I hear a song from it. It's a feeling I've never felt from her albums, so it's my least played. There is more power in her revealing what is wrong and owning it, rather than shutting it away (look at Celine) but ultimately it is her choice on whether or not to reveal it. She could have become a spokesperson for bipolar, to talk about it, spread awareness and understanding, hell could have even used it as a source of inspiration for songwriting (it would be the most vulnerable she would be in years ever since Petals), but instead released the information to beat Stella to it and has never spoken of it since. Again, it is her right to do so, but in not sharing it, she has become a prisoner of her own gilded cage. (Monday 27 July 2026; 01:09)

Madonna reached number 1 (114,299) by Bobby A from United States Madonna reconnected with the gay community with Confessions II. Besides the Lambs, who is really MC's other core audience? She has to reconnect with that core audience again. (Sunday 26 July 2026; 19:46) this is a reply to message 114,295

Madonna reached number 1 (114,295) by jaker20 from US Madonna connecting her new album to her last successful album (Confessions in 2005) was a great idea, so it connected with her legacy fans too who might have already abandoned her. She also had a collab with Sabrina Carpenter, who is popular right now. Mariah can't get that kind of collab anymore unfortunately. I don't think she has a good relationship with the biggest artists right now. Sadly, Madonna can actually still move on her own without assistance. The world seeing Mariah can't even walk on stage and if she does, she looks unstable and wobbly. Marian being assisted by Ariana to walk out of the VMA stage was a bad look that she won't be able to undo, now people think, she is, well, very old, sorry. Things like this matter in the eyes of public especially legacy artists. But I have to give credit to Mariah because her annual Christmas career is still bigger than Madonna's pop career, even though I think both their pop music careers are pretty much over if we're being honest because none of their recent songs (both of them) are making any impact whatsoever.. (Sunday 26 July 2026; 02:25)

Soulless (114,294) by Bobby A from United States Yes, we have to send good vibes to MC and lift her up in prayer. I listened to Here For It All and Nothing Is Impossible today. MC is still giving us some brillant and very personal songs. The glory, shakes, and withdrawals lyric from HFIA is very telling of her ups and downs during the past 15 years. (Sunday 26 July 2026; 01:12) this is a reply to message 114,284

Soulless (114,284) by Terna from Nigeria Nice observations but instead of us complaining, [we] her extended family with our unconditional love for her, can [pray] for her, I often do - [there] is power in [prayer]. That is what her very first song "Vision of Love" is all about. So I encourage you during the course of your day, when it comes to mind, pray for Mariah Carey. (Friday 24 July 2026; 11:56)

Glitter (114,281) by Bobby A from United States Let's show MC lots of love and make Glitter 25 her biggest anniversary streaming first couple of days. She is going to pour her heart and soul into Glitter 25. I just feel it. (Friday 24 July 2026; 02:30) this is a reply to message 114,280

Soulless (114,280) by Stacey from USA Whatever it is, it makes me sad to watch. (Thursday 23 July 2026; 21:02)

Soulless (114,279) by Bobby A from United States MC does need a lyric monitor to sing her songs during performances and videos. (Thursday 23 July 2026; 15:12) this is a reply to message 114,277

Soulless (114,277) by Lighty from China I wrote on this board last year or even earlier that I suspected Mariah had Alzheimer's or something like that, and then some yass queen called me out questioning me "Are you a medic?" I wonder how they feel about Mariah's situation now. (Thursday 23 July 2026; 14:26)

More depth to the interesting video (114,264) by Bobby A from United States I just thought about this. Did we miss MC's strange behavior and lack of movement in Mariah's World? Do you think Tanaka knows what is going on with MC and that is why their relationship ended? (Wednesday 22 July 2026; 00:31) this is a reply to message 114,258

More depth to the interesting video (114,258) by Bill from the UK I've added "James Packer conspiring to murder her" to my list of excuses as to why Mariah can't move or sing anymore. In my view it's probably as simple as her battling this mystery neurodegenerative disorder, whilst at the same time mixing prescription medication for her bipolar disorder with alcohol. (Tuesday 21 July 2026; 07:19)

More depth to the interesting video (114,256) by Bobby A from United States MC's life is filled with just as much scandal and disappointment as Madonna's life. There were two eras for them both that were hot topics for the media because of personal and career setbacks. MC can come back with a strong album just like Madonna did with Confessions II. MC needs to let go of her diva antics and return to her roots of letting her music shine and revisit that young woman on Vision of Love, Alone in Love, The Wind, and Looking In. MC: MIAM/James Packer and Glitter/post Charmbracelet Madonna: Erotica and American Life (Tuesday 21 July 2026; 03:53) this is a reply to message 114,253

More depth to the interesting video (114,253) by T from USA Ok, now we're getting somewhere. I had never put the connection together between leaving James Packer and screwing him out of so much money and the NYE fiasco. It does make perfect sense. She fired back on "Caution" with some pretty stingy songs but maybe he got the last laugh and had her mom and sister killed on the same day. It's been reported he's into some shady things and maybe he knows a lot of dangerous people. I wonder if Mariah feels guilt about that relationship now and all the trauma it's caused thereafter. Maybe hence the medication to cope. Or maybe the people drugging her are part of the conspiracy. (Tuesday 21 July 2026; 02:39)

Who is the meanest Pop girl (114,244) by Bobby A from United States This video is really good. (Monday 20 July 2026; 02:58) this is a reply to message 114,243

Who is the meanest Pop girl (114,243) by Lambi from USA The same creator made another video, and Mariah got a lot of airtime. Our girl is also winning, yet again, in the court of public opinion. Just read the comment section. She is undefeated with her wise mouth and quick wit. The 90s rivalries were so comical. (Monday 20 July 2026; 02:07)

Latest impromtu video (114,241) by Bobby A from United States I really feel MC is dealing with something with her physical health. It is something more than the effects of her bipolar meds. She appeared to deal with some pain when she was singing Underneath the Stars. I pray she will get better. (Monday 20 July 2026; 00:33)

Daydream 30 (114,239) by Bobby A from United States I understand better now. Thank you for explaining. Your post made me think about the other female powerhouse singer, Lara Fabian. Also, today I found a maxi CD of Tina Arena's Chains with various remixes. Do you have a copy? (Sunday 19 July 2026; 22:44) this is a reply to message 114,230

Daydream 30 (114,230) by Bill from the UK No really my dear friend as the instrumentation is synth and Mariah's voice is electronically enhanced. Here are some examples of what I would say are more traditional acapellas rather than just vocal stems. And of course. (Saturday 18 July 2026; 23:22)

MORE MESSAGES